How to Substitute Demi-Glace Without Losing Flavor or Texture
Share
Here's a little secret: despite being a demi-glace company; we don't always have demi-glace on hand. Even when we plan ahead, sometimes we want to swap it out to accommodate dietary restrictions. So whether you forgot to plan, or have a vegetarian coming over for dinner, we have a few demi-glace substitutions that we tend to use. Given the nature of a quick substitution, don't get worried about the specific ratios. Think of this as a framework to use when looking for substitutes. Just remember, you are looking to replicate a reduced sauce, so just keep the end goal in mind. That said, if we get a lot of questions, we can break out specific recipes below with measurements.
The idea is to find substitutions that accomplishes the following:Â
- Richness and body. The velvety mouthfeel that comes from bones, marrow, and patient reduction.
- Flavor depth and umami. Browning, tomato paste, mushrooms, aromatics, wine, and other savory boosters.
- Texture and thickness. A sauce that lightly coats meat and clings to a spoon without feeling pasty.
- Aroma and color. Caramelization and a deep brown hue set expectations before the first bite.
Demi-Glace Substitutes and When to Use Each
Times are realistic ranges for a home kitchen. Simmer gently, taste often, and adjust at the end.
| Substitute Style | How It Works | Approx Time | Best For | Watchouts and Fixes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shortcut using ready to go stock | Build flavor with mirepoix and tomato paste, add beef or veal stock, herbs, and reduce until concentrated. Strain. | 45–60 minutes | Weeknight sauces for steak, chops, or roast. Fast upgrade with real depth. | Stock may lack gelatin. Use low-sodium stock, reduce further if thin, finish with a small knob of butter for silkiness. |
| Shortcut with extra body | Use the above shortcut but take the extra step of adding a light roux, reduce heavily, then strain. | 45-60 minutes | When we want more complexity than a shortcut, without committing to a two-day project. | Salt concentrates as it reduces. Skim and strain well. Batch and freeze for later. |
| Vegetable or plant-based substitute | Roast mushrooms and vegetables hard for color, simmer with vegetable stock and tomato paste, reduce, and thicken if needed. | ~75–90 minutes | Vegetarian or vegan meals. Lighter sauces where we still want umami and color. | No natural gelatin. Rely on reduction and a small thickener. Season assertively to avoid flat flavors. |
| Emergency pantry boost | Use a concentrated base like Better Than Bullion, consommé or a good beef base with aromatics. Add tomato paste or wine. Reduce briefly and thicken as needed. | ~20–30 minutes | Last-minute sauces and flavor boosts when time and ingredients are limited. | Easy to over salt. Use modest amounts of base and balance acidity. Finish with fat for roundness. |
How-To: Four Practical Substitute Paths
1) Shortcut Demi-Glace Substitute (45–60 minutes)
- Sweat a few handfuls of finely chopped onion, carrot, and celery in a little fat until lightly browned.
- Add a spoonful of tomato paste and cook until it deepens in color.
- Add a few cups of beef or veal stock with a bay leaf, thyme, and a dozen or so peppercorns.
- High simmer until reduced by about half and lightly coats a spoon. Strain. Adjust salt at the end.Â
2) Cheater’s Demi-Glace With Roux (45-60 minutes)
- Sweat a few handfuls of finely chopped onion, carrot, and celery in a little fat until lightly browned.
- Add a spoonful of tomato paste and cook until it deepens in color.
- Add a few cups of beef or veal stock with a bay leaf, thyme, and a dozen or so peppercorns.
- Make a quick roux in a separate pan with few tablespoons of butter and flour. Aim for a pour-able texture. Cook, stirring regularly, until the stock has reduced.Â
- Simmer until reduced by about half and lightly coats a spoon. Strain. Combine with the roux. Adjust salt at the end.Â
3) Vegetable or Vegan Demi-Glace (~1 hour 15–80 minutes)
- Roast a few handfuls of mushrooms, onions, carrots, and any dark veg until well caramelized.Â
- Add a spoonful of tomato paste and cook until it deepens in color.
- Add a few cups of vegetable stock with bay leaf, thyme, and a dozen or so peppercorns.
- Simmer until reduced by about half and lightly coats a spoon. You may need to add a few pinches of corn starch for additional body. Strain. Adjust salt at the end.Â
4) Emergency Pantry Boost (~20–30 minutes)
- Combine a concentrated stock or consommé with a splash of red wine or a spoon of tomato paste.
- Simmer to round off sharp edges. If needed, thicken slightly and finish with cold butter off heat.
Trade-Offs and Smart Fixes
- If body is lacking, reduce a little further and finish with a touch of butter or rendered fat.
- Boost umami with mushrooms, soy, miso, tomato paste, or a dash of Worcestershire.
- Hold salt early. Reduction concentrates everything. Adjust at the end.
- Strain and degrease for a smooth, glossy finish.
- Keep the simmer gentle OR stay very active on stirring to avoid bitterness. Browning is good. Burnt is not. If we are working with limited time, it may make the most sense to keep the heat high and the stirring active.
Storage and Reheating
- Refrigerate in an airtight container for up to 5–7 days.Â
- Freeze in silicone molds or trays for easy use by the cube.
- Reheat gently and avoid a hard boil. If too thick, loosen with a splash of stock or water.
Keep Cooking With Us
- 5 Quick Demi-Glace Pan Sauces in 15 Minutes
- What Is Fond and How to Use It
- Grass-Fed Beef Demi-Glace and Roasted Chicken Demi-Glace
Â
